Here are the things I account for in order to like a song.

Atmosphere: (3 points)

Judges how I generally find the song as.

Mixing: (2 points)

Judges how well the song feels with each song note. (aka mixing)

Feeling: (2 points)

Just how epic it feels. Music only good for Geometry Dash levels don't apply here.

Emotion: (3 points)

How epic and fun the song is to listen to. Very subjective but hey. You gotta give your best shot at an objective opinion and not be too disingenuous about how good the song is. However don't be too biased and remember that no opinion is an objective fact. An objective opinion is your true opinion on the song, and not a fact.

Originality: (1 point)

Honestly I don't care if your song is unoriginal. I make sampled music all the time, but make sure your song is original enough to not get stuck in my head too much and as a result, be classified as an average song to me.

Not really a liminal space. It just reminded me of some liminal spaces. I like it. Btw getting point(s) for emotion in your song can get you a 9/10, 10/10 or 11/10.